Key messages on forest soils for multiple audiences

The HoliSoils project ended in October 2025 after 4.5 years of bringing experts and stakeholders to work together for forest soils across Europe and beyond.

The fruits of this collaboration included identification and testing of forest soil management practices aiming to mitigate climate change and sustain provision of ecosystem services, advances in the understanding of soil properties and dynamics, and better access to data about soil vulnerability and recovery potential.

The project also developed new methodologies and furthered knowledge on analytical techniques, data sharing, and model development, proposing ways to harmonise soil monitoring across Europe, and providing guidance on good management practices to optimise forest soil health.

HoliSoils partners distilled the findings generated by the project into several key messages which set the project’s scientific results into a broader context for forest soils, demonstrating how the work carried out in HoliSoils can support recommendations that could be taken up by various stakeholders for implementation in practice, policy, industry, or for use in education.

The key messages are presented according to four main topics, with three recommendations offered for each topic.

1.    Forest soil health impacts ecosystem services

Forest soils provide crucial services to people – from timber production to carbon sequestration and storage to mitigate climate change. Soils across European forest ecosystems contain vast amounts of carbon but they are regionally vulnerable to carbon loss. Forest management practices can be optimised to prevent carbon loss and enhance uptake.

Download Topic 1 key messages

2.    Forest soils contribute to reaching environmental goals

Forest management practices and forest use impact soil health in different ways. Climate-Smart Forestry (CSF) practices and sustainable post-disturbance recovery activities are beneficial for soil health, including biodiversity and carbon retention, as well as long-term productivity.

Download Topic 2 key messages

3.    Forest management impacts soil health

Forest soils are complex systems consisting of biotic and abiotic components engaged in physical, chemical and biological processes. Improved conceptual and simulation models have been developed that help to further understanding of soil functioning, vulnerability, recovery potential and to inform management decisions that promote and preserve soil health.

Download Topic 3 key messages

4.    Advanced forest soil monitoring is needed

Soils have been degraded and are vulnerable to degradation across Europe and the world. The EU Soil Monitoring Law aims to improve, maintain and safeguard soil health. Harmonised sampling and assessment methodologies are now available that help capture the particular considerations relevant to forest soils to ensure consistent reporting, balanced funding allocation and effective remedial action for the health of all soils across the EU.

Download Topic 4 key messages

Results and resources

HoliSoils’ results are also synthesised and tailored for various audiences, and the project has produced a number of hands-on tools that can be used by stakeholders including policy makers, practitioners, sector representatives, experts, learners and teachers in relevant disciplines, and lay audiences. These tailored HoliSoils results can be found in the resources section of the HoliSoils website, while the data, maps and models can be found directly in the HoliSoils toolkit.

Looking to the future

Though HoliSoils project has ended, its legacy lives on, and future investment could usefully be targeted towards further investigation into management impacts on soils, from the starting point offered by the advances made in the project. Additional research on soil function, biodiversity, and soil modelling would also be welcome to further inform policies, impact assessments, future predictions, and guide management practices for resilient forests. It is certainly the wish of all partners that stakeholders touched by HoliSoils can continue to work together for the health of our forest soils.

Explore all the HoliSoils’ key messages!

How do we support forest soils to foster a climate-smart future?

Forest soils can make a significant contribution in mitigating climate change. Not only do they store carbon and consume methane, with the right management they also store genetic diversity, teem with life and biodiversity, and support forests to be productive and resilient to climate change.

But for them to perform their full role, we need to know more about them, and how they can be managed effectively. “It is no secret that forest soils, in particular, are a big data gap”, acknowledged Jurij Krajcic of DG Clima of the European Commission (EC) in his opening words to the final HoliSoils policy forum, held in Brussels on 10 October.

The HoliSoils project has been working for the past 4.5 years on how to address this gap, and the policy forum brought HoliSoils’ leading researchers together with representatives from the main EC Directorate Generals, forest attachés to the European Union (EU), and industry and forest owner representatives to discuss what HoliSoils results mean for policy, industry, and ultimately practice in Europe.

In his opening address, Mr Krajcic reflected that forests, and the land sector in general, are the EU’s most important natural assets but are threatened by the impacts of climate change. More investment is needed, both in agriculture and in forests, and this requires incentives for forest management that increase forest resilience as well as forest growth. New EU carbon removals and carbon farming regulation was adopted late last year, and the EC is now seeking specific methodologies to operationalise that framework. He acknowledged the importance of forest soils in this policy context, underlining that robust monitoring, reporting and verification (MRV) is required, so that member states, value chains and private actors can make informed policy decisions.

HoliSoils project coordinator, Raisa Mäkipää of the Natural Resources Institute Finland (Luke), responded that HoliSoils has been working hard in this direction, with science providing enhanced understanding of soil processes and their drivers, and an understanding of ecosystem restoration practices and soil monitoring frameworks. HoliSoils offers new tools for MRV focussing particularly on the impact of management on forest soils, offering opportunities for the efficient implementation of the EU policies and regulations.

Raisa Mäkipää (Luke), HoliSoils project coordinator, addressing participants at the final Policy Forum in Brussels. Photo: Sarah Adams

From evidence to action: what HoliSoils science reveals

Leading HoliSoils experts then delved deeper into HoliSoils results and recommendations, focussing on four themes, in an animated presentation and discussion session moderated by Anne Ackermann of the European Forest Institute.

Jorge Curiel Yuste of the Basque Center for Climate Change (B3C) shared insights from extensive fieldwork on forests’ vulnerability to drought, leading to the development of productive soil vulnerability maps. He highlighted Mediterranean forests, where mineral soil carbon stocks are particularly large, to be of particular concern due to climate-driven changed in rainfall. He also emphasised soils’ varied role in forest ecosystem functioning, going significantly beyond its functions for carbon sequestration and storage, and offering multiple ecosystem services and benefits.

Bertrand Guenet of the French National Centre for Scientific Research, Paris (CNRS) talked about how soil models can quantify the impact of forest management on soils. This is complicated, as individual models are mathematical representations of dynamic behaviour, working on assumptions made by modellers, due to gaps in understanding of the mechanisms related to soil organic carbon decomposition. HoliSoils addressed this by developing an innovative multi-model approach, bringing together six existing state-of-the-art models into one tool. Recently launched via a user-friendly interface, the tool can be successfully run to show the effect of disturbance on soil.

Jorge Curiel Yuste (BC3) presents HoliSoils findings on forest vulnerability to drought and soil carbon dynamics during the Policy Forum. Photo: Sarah Adams.

Sara Filipek of Wageningen Environmental Research (WEnR) looked at future scenario models and how these might be used to develop effective climate-smart forestry (CSF) strategies in Europe. Different climate change scenarios affect potential forest development in different ways, in terms of biomass but also in the effects on soil carbon and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. While models are vital to inform strategy, she underlined that we need to understand these uncertainties, and advised that there are indeed opportunities to achieve climate benefits through different management practices, but one size does not fit all.

Sebastiaan Luyssaert of the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam then described work done to explore the synergies and trade-offs of potential CSF practices in Europe. One model does not fit all either, in this uncertain world, so another model  is used to account for demography, energy, and the carbon, water, and nitrogen cycles to simulate scenarios according to different climate conditions, and how different interventions would give different outcomes. This can be run for various processes and can give indications on maximising soil and litter carbon, soil function, wood production, and climate mitigation, as well as the compromises needed to meet the four objectives.

Sara Filipek (WEnR) and Sebastiaan Luyssaert (Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam) presented HoliSoils modelling approaches to support climate-smart forestry across Europe. Photo: Sarah Adams.

Closing remarks were given by HoliSoils project co-coordinator Aleksi Lehtonen, also from Luke, who highlighted the wealth of new data and tools developed by HoliSoils, noting that the project has already delivered a high number of publications and open-access results.  Despite these achievements, more is needed, and he emphasised that future funding could usefully be targeted towards further investigation into management impacts on soils, which would also support climate farming regulation. Additionally, further investment into research on soil function, biodiversity, and soil modelling would inform policies, impact assessments, and future predictions.

Explore HoliSoils results and policy insights

A synthesis of project outcomes for policymakers and practitioners is available on the HoliSoils website

The event was also livestreamed, and the recording is available on YouTube.

All speaker presentations from the final HoliSoils Policy forum are now available for download in this section.

Digging deeper: How AI is helping us understand the soil beneath our feet

Machine learning is helping scientists reveal key drivers of soil carbon storage, improving climate models and supporting better management of forests, farmland and natural ecosystems.

Soils may appear unremarkable, yet they are one of the planet’s most important climate regulators. They store more carbon than the atmosphere and all vegetation combined, and play a central role in global carbon cycling. Accurately predicting how much carbon they hold and how this might change in the future remains a major scientific challenge.

Recent research led by Dr Shoji Hashimoto (Forestry and Forest Products Research Institute, Japan) shows how machine learning is helping scientists to better understand soil carbon dynamics. Earth system models often struggle to reproduce real-world soil carbon measurements, leaving considerable uncertainty in climate projections. Machine learning can address this by analysing large global datasets to identify the factors that matter most.

The study found that while many models give significant weight to plant productivity, field data indicate that other influences are equally or more important. These include temperature, soil nitrogen, mineral content and land cover. By systematically comparing models with measured soil carbon stocks, researchers can detect missing processes and improve the performance of future models.

This work has implications beyond scientific modelling. A clearer picture of soil carbon storage supports more informed management of forests, farmland and natural ecosystems, strengthening strategies for climate change mitigation. As artificial intelligence methods continue to advance, they are becoming valuable tools for building models that reflect the full complexity of nature.

Read the full HoliSoils publication

Reference

Hashimoto, S., Bruni, E., Ťupek, B., Yamashita, N., Toriyama, J., Mori, T., Imaya, A., Guenet, B., Ito, A., & Lehtonen, A. (2025). Mining global soil carbon datasets: Can modern machine learning uncover the missing pieces of process-based models? Environmental Research Letters, 20(10), 101003. https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/adfe83


This summary was prepared in collaboration with Dr Shoji Hashimoto (Forestry and Forest Products Research Institute, Japan). The original article is openly accessible in Environmental Research Letters.

Nitrogen fertilisation boosts soil carbon storage in Scots pine forests

Forests play a vital role in global carbon storage, with most of this carbon held belowground. New HoliSoils research by the Natural Research Institute Finland (Luke) highlights mechanisms how nitrogen fertilisation of forest soils can enhance soil organic carbon (SOC) pools, offering a promising strategy for climate change mitigation.

The research team conducted a long-term fertilisation experiment in a Scots pine stand, combining chemistry, microbiology, and greenhouse gas flux measurements. The goal was to uncover the mechanisms behind the observed increase in soil carbon following nitrogen addition.

Nitrogen fertilisation increased carbon stocks, microbial biomass, necromass and the activity of extracellular enzymes, with no significant increase in greenhouse gas production. Moreover, nitrogen fertilisation decreased the production of a group of plant secondary metabolites, tannins. These profound changes were observed in the organic layer of the soil, and differences in the mineral soil were less detectable.

The results suggest that increased plant litter, fungal biomass and fungal necromass stabilised in the soil are the mechanisms behind the increase in the SOC pool, rather than changes in the composition of the fungal community, the suppression of decomposition of recalcitrant SOC or changes in pH.

“Our research supports the idea that nitrogen fertilisation can be used to increase microbial necromass in persistent carbon pools in forest soil. This approach could be an effective tool in forest management strategies aimed at mitigating climate change”, concludes Sylwia Adamczyk, Senior Scientist at Luke.

The research adds to growing evidence that targeted soil management practices can significantly impact carbon dynamics in forest ecosystems.

Read the full HoliSoils pubblication




This article was written by the Natural Resources Institute Finland (Luke).

More information:

Adamczyk, B., Adamczyk, S., Tupek, B., Li, Q., Martinovic, T., Richy, E., Lehtonen, A., Baldrian, P., & Mäkipää, R. (2025). Nitrogen fertilisation of boreal forest soil increases soil carbon pool through elevated microbial necromass formation but also modifies tree secondary metabolism. Soil Biology and Biochemistry, 109917. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soilbio.2025.109917

Forest soil monitoring in focus as EU Soil Monitoring Law advances

Forest roots

There is increasing recognition at international level of the pivotal importance held by soils and their health for the future of our planet and its people. The first ever European Union Soil Monitoring Law (SML) will likely enter into force this autumn following provisional agreement by the Council and Parliament of the EU earlier this year. This important directive aims to establish a shared framework for soil monitoring to enhance their resilience and mitigate the risks posed by contamination.

To ensure that the SML achieves its intended impact, Member States will need to adopt effective sampling-based soil monitoring practices that provide accurate information on the status of and trends in soil carbon stocks, nutrient levels, and biodiversity. However, particularly for forest soils, gaps in existing methodologies mean that such empirical information is not currently available at all, or does not capture the full range of forest soils across the EU. Furthermore, rigorous soil sampling practices and sampling protocols that account for the biologically active layer of forest soils are lacking, presenting an additional challenge. This results in a lack of comprehensiveness, coherence, and reliability of soil information.

HoliSoils is addressing these challenges through the development of a monitoring methodology that accounts for the specificities of forest soils, as well as the variation in forest soil types across the EU.

As highlighted in a new policy brief from the European Forest Institute (EFI), based on HoliSoils’ findings, this harmonised methodology is crucial to facilitate comparability of forest soil monitoring data and findings across news the EU in three main ways:

  1. Development and testing of a harmonised methodology to measure forest soil carbon fluxes and stock changes that can be used in national GHG inventories.
  2. Identification and testing of advanced soil models that are applicable to national GHG inventories.
  3. Development and testing of a harmonised methodology for the analyses of soil microbial and faunal communities.

The policy brief also includes recommendations for EU and national policy makers to ensure that the requirements of the EU SML are met, and its goals are achieved. Firstly, all Member States should adopt the HoliSoils’ harmonised methodology for forest soil monitoring. Policy makers should also foster the use of forest soil monitoring networks and protocols developed by HoliSoils that build on existing work and include DNA-based methodology to assess soil biodiversity. Finally, a continuous dialogue with scientists and experts should be ensured to access the latest scientific knowledge to enhance soil health.

Read the full policy brief

Explore all the HoliSoils’ policy briefs

How does thinning affect forest carbon? A look at an upland and a drained peatland forest

Peatland forest

Thinning, the practice of removing some trees to help others grow better, changes how much carbon a forest stores or releases. We studied this effect in two forest types: an upland forest on mineral soil, and a peatland forest drained for forestry many years ago. We measured carbon storage and emissions in trees, forest floor plants, soil, and deadwood, both before and after thinning.

We found that thinning caused an immediate drop in annual carbon accumulation, especially in tree biomass, as many trees were removed. But within a year, the forest began to recover. Thinning also contributed to increased carbon emissions due to higher carbon release from decomposition of harvest residues.

In the upland forest, recovery was relatively fast. Forest floor plants like mosses and shrubs took advantage of the extra light and space, helping to absorb more carbon. One year after thinning, this site went from a temporary carbon-emitting source to a carbon sink again.

In the peatland forest, which was already a carbon source before thinning, tree removal intensified carbon emissions. Even one year after thinning, the forest continued to release more carbon than it absorbed. This was due to slow tree growth combined with ongoing emissions from the soil and leftover harvest residues such as branches and stumps.

Forest
Photo: Gonzalo de Quesada.

This is important because thinning affects more than just the trees; it alters the entire carbon balance of the forest ecosystem. In upland forests, carbon storage can recover within a few years. However, in drained peatlands, recovery may be slower, and these forests might continue to release carbon for some time after thinning. This study is a case study of two forests, and additional research, particularly in drained peatlands, is needed to better understand the broader impacts of thinning. As Finland and other countries pursue their climate goals, it is essential to understand how different forest types respond to management practices. Sustainable forestry must balance timber production with maintaining forests as effective carbon sinks, especially in sensitive ecosystems such as drained peatlands.

For a detailed discussion of methods and findings, see the original study by de Quesada et al. (2025).




This article was written by Gonzalo de Quesada (University of Helsinki).

More information:

de Quesada, G., Rautakoski, H., Xu, J., Li, Q., Larmola, T., Salovaara, P., Anttila, V., Peltoniemi, M., Koskinen, M., Lohila, A., Aalto, J., Lehtonen, L., Bäck, J., Mäkipää, R., Heinonsalo, J., Salmon, Y., & Lintunen, A. (2025). Carbon dynamics after thinning in two boreal forest sites: Upland and drained peatland. Forest Ecology and Management, 595, 123024. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foreco.2025.123024

HoliSoils sheds light on GHG emissions in peatlands at INTECOL Conference 2025

HoliSoils researchers in Tartu for the 12th INTECOL Wetlands Conference.

The 12th INTECOL Wetlands Conference took place together with the 20th Annual Meeting of SWS Europe from 29 June to 4 July 2025 in Tartu, Estonia. The event aimed to advance wetland management by promoting the exchange of ideas, knowledge, and experiences among researchers, practitioners, and policymakers from across the world.

Among the many insightful sessions, workshops, and technical tours, HoliSoils took centre stage in a dedicated symposium on drivers and processes of Soil CO₂, CH₄, and N₂O emissions in forested peatlands. Boris Tupek organised this ‘HoliSoils session’ together with Raisa Mäkipää, Tuula Larmola, Qian Li, Eduardo Martínez García from Natural Resources Institute Finland (LUKE).

Forested peatlands serve as substantial carbon sinks, yet they also act as sources of greenhouse gases (GHGs), releasing CO₂, CH₄, and N₂O. Understanding the drivers and processes behind these emissions is essential for predicting how climate and land-use changes will affect GHG balances and the role of forested peatlands in mitigating climate change. This ‘HoliSoils session’ brought together empirical and modeling studies focused on the mechanisms influencing GHG emissions from forested peatlands. The symposium gathered contributions investigating the factors driving these emissions, including environmental drivers, disturbance effects, management methods, biogeochemical processes and microbial contributions.

To learn more, you can browse the book of abstracts and view the HoliSoils presentation online!

HoliSoils researchers in Tartu for the 12th INTECOL Wetlands Conference.

HoliSoils research explores the long-term impacts of clear-cutting on soil carbon

Finnish forest

Clear-cutting as a forest management practice is often criticized for its environmental impacts, but the practice and its consequences are actively debated. While clear-cutting temporarily turns forests into carbon sources rather than carbon sinks, these changes also have lasting effects, particularly on C stocks, that need to be understood over complete forest rotations.

Focusing on soil organic carbon (SOC), researchers studied two long-term forest monitoring sites in Finland (Scots pine and Norway spruce) that had been clear-cut and where SOC stocks time series have recently been measured. They used a soil carbon model (Yasso) to assimilate all the information from the data and then clear-cutting with a reference set-aside scenario over more than one full forest rotation.

The results of the modelling exercise, published in a new paper, showed that while thinnings operations didn’t significantly affect carbon storage, clear-cutting had major impacts. Each clear-cut event created negative soil carbon balance for decades, and it took 37-69 years for the forest soils to reach a break-even point where new carbon uptake compensated for the carbon lost. The biggest sources of carbon emissions after clear-cutting came from leftover harvest materials, followed by dead roots and fallen leaves.

When comparing managed forests to unmanaged ones, the clear-cut areas had negative soil carbon budgets until the next thinning or even the next clear-cut, while unmanaged forests consistently stored carbon in their soils. This suggests that forest carbon studies ignoring long-term soil effects may reach misleading conclusions, and that rotation forestry could not be a very effective management approach if carbon storage is a priority.

Explore the full publication!




This article was written by Lorenzo Menichetti (Natural Resources Institute Finland).

More information:

Menichetti, L., A. Lehtonen, A.-J. Lindroos, et al. 2025. “Soil Carbon Dynamics During Stand Rotation in Boreal Forests.” European Journal of Soil Science 76, no. 4: e70154. https://doi.org/10.1111/ejss.70154.

HoliSoils at the forefront of the 2025 Ecology of Soil Microorganisms conference

Forest dynamics

The Ecology of Soil Microorganisms 2025 conference in Helsinki brought together leading researchers focused on soil microbial ecology and ecosystem functioning. The HoliSoils project had a strong presence throughout the event, contributing both field-based insights and the latest research on soil health and microbial communities.

Exploring an HoliSoils test site

The conference began with a pre-conference excursion to Ränskälänkorpi, a HoliSoils test site in a drained peatland forest. Guided by two HoliSoils team members (Qian Li and Tijana Martinović), together with two more scientists from Luke (Tiina Törmänen and Sakari Sarkkola) participants explored field experiments investigating gas flux dynamics, extensive measurements collected by the eddy covariance tower, forest management practices, and microbial responses to disturbances.

Discussing HoliSoils research during the sessions

Picture: Tijana Martinović.

The HoliSoils consortium made significant scientific contributions that were highlighted throughout the programme.

During the session Forest and peatland soils, Sylwia Adamczyk presented how nitrogen addition affects microbial necromass and tree secondary metabolism, while Alexandre Raimbault spoke about short-term microbial responses to forest harvesting.

In Microbial networks and habitats, in his keynote Petr Baldrian addressed fungal and bacterial dynamics in soil, Bartosz Adamczyk introduced biochemical tools for microbial research, and Qian Li showed the impacts of soil disturbance on GHG emissions and microbial communities.

In European soil health, biodiversity, and sustainable management session, Tijana Martinović presented the HoliSoils project and shared the results on root exclusion effects on microbial and biogeochemical processes across European forests. She also participated as a panelist in the discussion that followed.

Picture: Tijana Martinović.
Picture: Tijana Martinović.

In the Soil carbon and nutrient cycles poster session, Etienne Richy presented work on phosphorus limitation impact on soil carbon accumulation under long-term nitrogen input, while Daniela Guasconi showed how forest management and microbial diversity affect soil respiration. Lorenzo Menichetti presented the ecological drivers of organic matter temperature sensitivity in forest soils across Europe.

Shaping the future of soil health in Europe

HoliSoils strong presence throughout the event underlined its leading role in European soil microbial research. The diversity of contributions reflected the project’s interdisciplinary scope, from ecosystem-scale experiments to molecular insights into microbial function.

Explore the presentations and posters of the HoliSoils’ scientist at the event!

Sylwia Adamczyk, Alexandre Raimbault, Bartosz Adamczyk, and Qian Li presenting the project results. Pictures: Béraud Cédric.

Size matters: how forest disturbances disproportionately impact soil organisms

Mesofauna in HoliSoils sample.

Worldwide forests are currently facing increasing disturbances caused by climatic and anthropogenic pressures, including those driven by the increasing demand for biomass, which threaten forest biodiversity and limit their ability to maintain sustainable productivity and long-term stability.

In this context, as a group of HoliSoils researchers, we asked how and to what extent soil organisms (including all the spectrum of body sizes) may respond to forest canopy disturbances, and if the effect of the disturbance can be attenuated by post-disturbance management practices. For that, we have inventoried a large proportion of the soil biota present in the soil.

Our quite unique multi-taxon study has showed that the effects of forest disturbance on soil organisms are more severe as the size of the organisms and the disturbance intensity increase. Changes in the organism body size distribution due to the disturbance could imply further long-term consequences for soil functioning.

Diplopoda
Diplopoda from the HoliSoils test site in Gamiz, Spain. Picture: Charlotte Biryol.

Yet, protecting the soil in the short term after disturbance with an artificial litter layer derived from the forest harvest residues seems to be the key to avoid detrimental effects on soil biota and favours its recovery, and should therefore be given more consideration when designing forest practices that aim to export debris for biofuel.

Pictures: Charlotte Biryol.

Read the full publication for more details!




This article was written by Leticia Pérez-Izquierdo (BC3-Basque Centre for Climate Change).

More information:

Pérez-Izquierdo, L., Ménival, C., Baldrian, P., Baldy, V., Biryol, C., Gros, R., Hereş, A.-M., Le Bagousse-Pinguet, Y., Martinovic, T., Petritan, I.C., Sánchez-Moreno, S., Santonja, M. and Curiel Yuste, J. (2025), Impacts of Canopy Disturbances by Tree Logging on Soil Biota Increase With Organism Size. Glob Change Biol, 31: e70287. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.70287